Zakat cannot be given to non-Muslims, to a mosque or its construction, to a madrasa building, to a Syed or other member of Banu Hashim (in the mainstream Hanafi view), to anyone who owns the nisab, or to your own parents, children or spouse. The reason is the same in every case: Zakat must be transferred into the personal ownership (tamleek) of a poor or needy Muslim from the eight categories named in Surah At-Tawbah (9:60). A building cannot own anything; a non-Muslim is outside the categories; a wealthy person is not needy; a dependant’s upkeep is already your duty. Each of these groups can — and should — be helped with Sadaqah, Lillah or other voluntary giving. This guide works through every common “can Zakat be given to…” question asked in Pakistan, with the ruling, the reasoning, and the right alternative.
![A mosque under construction in Karachi with a donation box at the gate]
—
Zakat is not a donation to a cause; it is a transfer of ownership to a person. Classical jurists call the condition tamleek — making the recipient the owner. The Quran lists who those owners may be: the poor (fuqara), the needy (masakin), Zakat administrators, those whose hearts are to be reconciled, captives, debtors, in the way of Allah, and stranded travellers (9:60). Our guide to who is eligible for Zakat explains each category.
Every exclusion below follows from tamleek or from the list. Where tamleek is impossible — a wall, a well, a salary for a service — Zakat is not discharged. Where the person is outside the list — a non-Muslim, a wealthy relative — Zakat is not discharged. Where the money would benefit the giver — paying a dependant, paying an employee for work — Zakat is not discharged. Understanding the principle makes the individual rulings easy to predict.
—
No. The four Sunni schools agree that Zakat must be given to a Muslim, because the Prophet ﷺ described it as “taken from their rich and given to their poor” (Bukhari and Muslim) — the pronoun referring to the Muslim community. Non-Muslims in need should be helped generously, but with Sadaqah, not Zakat.
The one category some scholars connect to non-Muslims is “those whose hearts are to be reconciled” (mu’allafat al-qulub), used by the Prophet ﷺ for new or prospective Muslims. The Hanafi school holds that this category lapsed after Islam was established; other schools retain it narrowly. It does not open Zakat to non-Muslims generally.
This matters in Pakistan, where Christian and Hindu families are among the poorest in many districts. They are entitled to our charity — the Quran commands kindness to all who do not fight us (Surah Al-Mumtahanah, 60:8) — and the right vehicle is Sadaqah, Lillah or general donation. Many trusts, including Amanatdaar, serve non-Muslim families from non-Zakat funds for exactly this reason.
—
No. A mosque cannot own money, so tamleek is impossible. The same applies to buying land for a mosque, paying for its electricity, carpets, water or repairs, and paying the imam or muezzin a salary from Zakat (that is a wage for a service, not a gift to the poor). Mosque projects are among the best Sadaqah Jariyah — but they must come from non-Zakat funds.
The phrase “in the way of Allah” (fi sabilillah) in 9:60 is sometimes cited to justify Zakat for mosques. The overwhelming classical view limits that category to poor fighters and, by extension in the Hanafi school, poor students of knowledge and poor pilgrims — individuals who become owners of the money. A minority of modern scholars extend it to Islamic institutions; the mainstream Pakistani position, including Darul Uloom Karachi, does not. The safe course is to fund mosques from Sadaqah and give Zakat to people.
—
It depends on what the madrasa does with it. Zakat may not be spent on the madrasa building, land, furniture, utilities or teachers’ salaries, for the same tamleek reason. Zakat may be given to the madrasa’s poor students — food, stipends, books, medical costs — provided the madrasa acts as the students’ agent (wakil) and makes each student the owner of what he receives.
This is why reputable madrasas in Pakistan keep two accounts: a Zakat account, used only for eligible students’ personal needs, and a Lillah account, used for everything else. When giving Zakat to a madrasa, ask which account it goes into, and prefer institutions that can show the separation. Supporting a Hifz student’s living costs through a trust is the same principle at work — see Amanatdaar’s Hifz sponsorship programme, where Zakat funds eligible students’ expenses and Lillah funds the institution.
Some madrasas use a formal hila (device) in which Zakat is given to a poor student who then voluntarily donates it to the institution. Most Pakistani scholars discourage this as a routine practice; it is better to give Zakat to the student and Sadaqah to the madrasa separately.
![A madrasa student in Karachi receiving a meal and a stipend from a trust worker]
—
In the mainstream Hanafi view followed in Pakistan, no. The Prophet ﷺ said: “Charity is not permitted for the family of Muhammad; it is the dirt of people’s hands” (Muslim). Jurists extended this to Banu Hashim — the descendants of Ali, Jafar, Aqil, Abbas and Harith — which in South Asia is understood to mean Syeds and Hashmis.
The practical difficulty is that many Syed families in Pakistan are poor, and the alternative provision for them — a share of state revenue (khums or fay) — no longer exists. Contemporary scholars have responded in two ways. Mufti Taqi Usmani and most Hanafi muftis hold that the prohibition stands, and that poor Syeds must be supported through Sadaqah, Lillah, gifts and Qarz-e-Hasna, which the community should give generously. A minority of scholars, including some in the Shafi’i school and some contemporary Hanafi voices, permit Zakat to a Syed in genuine need when no other provision exists.
The safe course for a donor: do not give Zakat to a Syed; give Sadaqah and gifts instead, and give more because of the restriction, not less.
—
Zakat cannot be used to pay wages, bonuses or anything owed in return for work; that is compensation, not charity. A poor employee may, however, receive Zakat as a separate gift over and above her wages, if she meets the conditions — Muslim, below the nisab, not your dependant. Many families in Karachi give their domestic helper’s Eid gift or a child’s school fees from Zakat; that is valid provided it is clearly extra and the helper owns it outright.
Two cautions. If the “Zakat” is in practice replacing a fair wage, it is not Zakat. And if the employee is a Syed, the Hanafi restriction above applies.
—
A person who owns the nisab — in gold, cash, trade goods, or surplus assets beyond basic needs — cannot receive Zakat, however honourable their work. Zakat also cannot be given to a parent, grandparent, child, grandchild or spouse, because their support is already the giver’s duty and the money would circle back to the giver’s own obligations. It can be given to poor siblings, uncles, aunts, cousins, nephews, nieces and in-laws, who are often the best recipients. Our guide on whether you can give Zakat to family sets out each relationship.
A debtor who owns assets above the nisab but is unable to pay a debt is a special case under the gharimin category — see can Zakat be used to pay off debt.
—
The same two-account logic applies. Zakat may fund a poor patient’s treatment, medicines and tests, a poor student’s fees and books, or food and cash for a flood-affected family — because in each case a person becomes the owner of the benefit. Zakat may not fund the hospital building, the school’s roof, a handpump, a water tanker for a village, or a trust’s administrative costs, because no eligible person owns those.
Well-run trusts solve this by applying Zakat only to beneficiary-level costs and charging capital and overheads to Sadaqah and Lillah. When you give to a charity, ask whether it maintains that separation. Amanatdaar funds its handpumps, water stations and buildings from the Sadaqah-e-Jariya programme, and its rations, medical aid, education guardianship and livelihood grants to verified families from the Zakat fund.
—
Proposed recipient | Zakat valid? | Reason | Give instead |
Non-Muslim in need | No | Outside the eight categories | Sadaqah, general donation |
Mosque construction or running costs | No | No tamleek; a building cannot own | Sadaqah Jariyah, Lillah |
Imam’s or muezzin’s salary | No | Wage for service | Lillah, mosque fund |
Madrasa building, furniture, teachers | No | No tamleek | Lillah |
Madrasa’s poor students (via agent) | Yes | Student becomes owner | Zakat to the Zakat account |
Syed / Banu Hashim | No (mainstream Hanafi) | Hadith prohibition | Sadaqah, gifts, Qarz-e-Hasna |
Employee’s wages or bonus | No | Compensation, not charity | Fair pay; Zakat as a separate gift if eligible |
Poor employee, as a separate gift | Yes | Eligible individual | — |
Person owning the nisab | No | Not poor or needy | Gifts, Sadaqah |
Parents, children, spouse | No | Giver’s own duty | Maintenance, gifts |
Poor siblings, uncles, cousins, in-laws | Yes | Eligible, and relatives | — |
Hospital building or equipment | No | No tamleek | Sadaqah Jariyah |
Poor patient’s treatment | Yes | Patient becomes owner | — |
Handpump or water project | No | No tamleek | Sadaqah Jariyah |
Flood-affected family, cash or rations | Yes | Eligible individuals | — |
Charity’s administrative costs | No (mainstream) | No tamleek | Sadaqah, Lillah |
Deceased person’s funeral or debts | No | Deceased cannot own | Sadaqah on their behalf |
—
The rules can feel restrictive, but they exist to guarantee that Zakat does what the Quran says it does: moves wealth from those who have it into the hands of those who do not. A mosque funded by Zakat is a beautiful building paid for with money that should have fed a widow. A trust that spends Zakat on its vehicles has quietly reduced the amount reaching the poor. Keeping Zakat for people, and Sadaqah for everything else, protects the giver’s obligation and the recipient’s right.
For the difference between the two forms of giving in detail, see our guide to the difference between Zakat and Sadaqah.
—
Through its Zakat programme, Amanatdaar Welfare Trust applies Zakat strictly at beneficiary level — monthly rations, medical treatment, school fees and books, widow support and livelihood grants — for families its case workers have verified as Muslim, below the nisab and not otherwise provided for. Buildings, water projects, non-Muslim beneficiaries and administration are funded from Sadaqah and Lillah. As a registered trust in Pakistan, the trust is audited annually and keeps its Zakat and non-Zakat accounts separate.
Perspective from Amanatdaar Welfare Trust: “The most common question we are asked is not ‘where does my Zakat go’ but ‘are you sure this family qualifies.’ We treat that as the right question. Every Zakat beneficiary on our list has been visited, their income and assets recorded, and their eligibility confirmed before the first rupee is paid. Where a family does not qualify — because of a Syed lineage, or because they are not Muslim — we help them, but from a different fund, and we tell the donor so.”
—
—
![An Amanatdaar case worker verifying a family’s eligibility at their home]
No, according to all four Sunni schools; Zakat is for poor Muslims. Non-Muslims in need should be helped with Sadaqah or general donations, which carry their own reward.
No. A mosque cannot own money, so the condition of tamleek fails. Mosque construction and running costs are excellent Sadaqah Jariyah but must come from non-Zakat funds.
Only for its poor students’ personal needs — food, stipends, books, medical costs — with the madrasa acting as their agent. It cannot fund the building, furniture or salaries. Ask for the madrasa’s Zakat account.
Not in the mainstream Hanafi view, based on the hadith that Sadaqah is not permitted for the Prophet’s family. Poor Syeds should be helped with Sadaqah, gifts and interest-free loans. A minority of scholars allow Zakat in genuine need.
Not as wages or a bonus. You can give an eligible employee Zakat as a separate, extra gift that she owns outright — for example, her child’s school fees — provided she is Muslim, below the nisab and not a Syed.
Not to the building or equipment. It can pay a poor patient’s treatment and medicines, with the hospital or trust acting as the patient’s agent.
Not in the mainstream view; overheads must come from Sadaqah or Lillah. Choose charities that keep Zakat and non-Zakat accounts separate and say so.
—
Zakat has a narrow door by design. It goes to people, not projects; to Muslims, not everyone; to the poor, not the comfortable; to those outside your own household, not inside it; and, in the mainstream view, not to the Prophet’s family. Every one of the groups outside that door deserves our generosity — through Sadaqah, Lillah, gifts and Qarz-e-Hasna, given freely and in greater measure because of the restriction.
When you give Zakat, give it where eligibility is verified and the accounts are kept separate: Amanatdaar’s Zakat programme, a registered, audited trust serving Karachi’s most deserving families.
Subscribe to our Newsletter. We promise not to spam you!